![AI for Physics: certified bounds, exact seeds and bug reports on published physics software](assets/banner.png) # ai-physics **AI for Physics.** Physics results I've run with AI agents, in one place. Every item names the published paper it starts from, what was asked, what I found, how an independent referee checked it, and where it is still a candidate. All of it has been sent to the author it concerns. What was easy, what was hard, and what is still open: [RETRO.md](RETRO.md). Every result in one file, with its claim, derivation, checks and verdict copied from the result folders: [PAPER.md](PAPER.md). Sister hubs: [AI for biology](https://github.com/rpinho/ai-biology) · [math](https://github.com/rpinho/math-certificates) · [astronomy](https://github.com/rpinho/planet-hunt) ## What this is, and what it isn't A physicist I studied with put the objection plainly: a number alone isn't worth much without new physics or new intuition behind it. I think he's right, and most of what is below is a tightening, a closed form or a software defect rather than new physics. It is labelled that way. Brian Armstrong's November 7 [post](https://x.com/brian_armstrong/status/2119150702446420027) is the format argument: every experiment as a repo, data and code versioned, replication rewarded. Some referenced evidence isn't included in this repository. **Referee verdicts** are the separate agent's words: HOLDS, HOLDS WITH CAVEATS, CONFIRMED, CONFIRMED-MINOR. Nothing here has been refereed by a journal, and no priority is claimed. ## Results ### João Penedones — de Sitter bootstrap bound - **Paper:** Hogervorst, Penedones and Salehi Vaziri, *Towards the non-perturbative cosmological bootstrap*, [arXiv:2107.13871](https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.13871), equation (5.53). - **Asked:** can the printed bound be improved, with a certificate? - **Found:** 5.67049 → **5.45808**, with an independent interval certification over all 61 closed intervals of the spectrum. - **Checked:** HOLDS WITH CAVEATS. The referee rebuilt the functional from the paper with 640-bit Arb arithmetic and explicit truncation bounds, and its trivial controls fail where they should (a single degree-1 term gives 10.876; deleting degree 5 looks better but breaks positivity at n=6). The caveat: the eight functionals behind the paper's printed 5.67049 aren't public, so the baseline comes from the paper rather than a rerun. - **Honest framing:** this is a numerical tightening of a demonstration bound, not new physics. [Claim, derivation, referee](friends/penedones-de-sitter-bootstrap/). ### Pedro Vieira — a closed single-light-cone seed, and what its ODE is - **Paper:** Olivucci and Vieira, *Stampedes I*, [arXiv:2111.12131](https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.12131), section 4 and appendix E, which asks for a closed resummation of the single-light-cone seed series. - **Found:** a closed form for that seed (X004), after all 30 entries of the paper's printed table were reproduced first. HOLDS WITH CAVEATS: it reformulates an existing exact determinant (Kostov, Petkova and Serban, [arXiv:1905.11467](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.11467)) rather than extending its coverage. - **Follow-up, after the two questions that came back:** the result is not in *Stampedes II*, and the ODE is exactly the zero-angular-momentum radial Coulomb scattering equation in two dimensions, with L as radius, B as charge and energy π². That gives a logarithmic Coulomb phase and shows increasing B delays every positive zero; its double-scaling limit recovers the Bessel seed of *Stampedes II*. A separate referee agrees with the algebra and the limits. - **Honest framing:** explanatory consequences of an existing seed, not a new physical discovery. [X004](friends/vieira-stampedes-seed/x004/) · [the Coulomb follow-up](friends/vieira-stampedes-seed/coulomb-follow-up/). ### Artur Alho — Signorini balls and certified Padé approximations - **Papers:** Alho and Calogero, [arXiv:1907.09970](https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.09970) §6.4; Alho, Hell and Uggla, [arXiv:1503.06994](https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.06994), Table 1; Alho and Uggla, *New simple and accurate quintessence approximations*, [arXiv:2407.14378](https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.14378). - **Found:** - **O004 (HOLDS):** an existence theorem where the published work left numerical evidence — for every −1 < ν < 1/2 and every prescribed δ_c > 1, a strongly regular static quasi-linear Signorini ball with finite radius, positive density and positive interior principal pressures. - **O010 (HOLDS WITH CAVEATS):** the n = 20 [4/4] Padé approximant gives a certified relative Hubble error below 0.000067% at the same endpoint where the paper's best printed row has 31%, with n = 30, 50 and 100 rows added. Exact rational certificates, no fitting. - **O011 (HOLDS):** certified uniform error bounds for the tracking approximation over the full interval 0 ≤ z ≤ 6: Ω_m below 0.0014% and E below 0.0007% for both p = 1 and p = 1/10. The normalization change from the source is disclosed and controlled separately. - [Claims, proofs, certificates and verdicts](friends/alho-signorini-and-pade/). ### Tiago Fonseca (with Paul Zinn-Justin) — a fused-link obstruction - **Paper:** Fonseca and Zinn-Justin, *Higher spin polynomial solutions of the quantum Knizhnik–Zamolodchikov equation*, [arXiv:1212.4672](https://arxiv.org/abs/1212.4672), appendix C.2. - **Found:** W011, an exact counterexample to the literal reading of the fused-link map at the special q, with the ordinary Chevalley-generated algebra. At ℓ = 3, L = 6 the image dimension is 34 against 35 strict-weight-zero ordinary invariants. - **Checked:** HOLDS WITH CAVEATS, reconstructed independently. The caveat matters: it is an obstruction for the ordinary algebra form, and is not a counterexample if the intended codomain uses Lusztig's divided powers. [Claim, audit, verdict](friends/fonseca-dinis-qkz-fused-link/). ### Aires Ferreira — KITE - **Who and what:** [Aires Ferreira](https://www.york.ac.uk/physics/people/ferreira/), University of York; [KITE](https://github.com/quantum-kite/kite) is the open quantum-transport code he co-develops ([Comput. Phys. Commun. 2020](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpc.2020.107676)). - **Found:** 4 confirmed bugs on a fresh clone. The top one: KITE-tools prints the temperature read from the file and then ignores it in both optical-conductivity branches, so finite-temperature optical results are computed at the wrong temperature. Also: a nonzero onsite energy shift invents interorbital couplings even for diagonal matrices; the documented Green LDOS kernel is too large by a factor of π; a non-divisible moment count silently loses its remainder across threads. One further candidate was judged intended behaviour and dropped. - **Checked:** a separate referee reproduced each on its own clone, reading only the claim document — [verdicts and ranking](friends/ferreira-kite/VERDICTS.md), [patch](friends/ferreira-kite/combined.patch). ### Carlos Guedes — Duflo and symmetric quantization maps, a correction - **Paper:** Guedes, Oriti and Raasakka, *Quantization maps, algebra representation and non-commutative Fourier transform for Lie groups*, *J. Math. Phys.* 54 (2013), [arXiv:1301.7750](https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.7750), section 5.2. - **Found:** - **CG004 (HOLDS):** the printed symmetric and Duflo cubic examples don't follow from the paper's own defining maps. An erratum-type result, read against the arXiv v2 and the journal version. - **CG456 (HOLDS):** the corrected and extended coordinate-word table through length 4; all 360 inverse images agree exactly with an independent rebuild. - **Honest framing:** a correction to worked examples, not to the paper's main construction. [Claims and verdicts](friends/guedes-flm-identities/). ## Pull requests 53 PRs to 14 repositories: 5 merged, 43 open, 5 closed. The table is in [fixing-research-software](https://github.com/rpinho/fixing-research-software#physics-and-astronomy). ## Not here - Results that have not been sent to the author they concern. - Mathematics that happens to be done by physicists lives in the [math hub](https://github.com/rpinho/math-certificates); the TESS exoplanet search lives in [planet-hunt](https://github.com/rpinho/planet-hunt). ## How this was run AI agents under a bounded harness, [rstack](https://github.com/rpinho/rstack): the claim and its kill line are frozen before the search, the published baseline is reproduced first, the referee is a different agent on a different model that may not import the finder's code, and prior art is re-run rather than quoted. ## References Everything here builds on other people's papers and code. - Brian Armstrong, [publicly funded science as open source](https://x.com/brian_armstrong/status/2119150702446420027), November 7, 2026. - Hogervorst, Penedones and Salehi Vaziri, [arXiv:2107.13871](https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.13871). - Olivucci and Vieira, *Stampedes I*, [arXiv:2111.12131](https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.12131); Kostov, Petkova and Serban, [arXiv:1905.11467](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.11467). - Alho and Calogero, [arXiv:1907.09970](https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.09970); Alho, Calogero and Liljenberg, [arXiv:2104.11131](https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.11131); Alho, Hell and Uggla, [arXiv:1503.06994](https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.06994); Alho and Uggla, [arXiv:2407.14378](https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.14378). - Fonseca and Zinn-Justin, [arXiv:1212.4672](https://arxiv.org/abs/1212.4672), *Comm. Math. Phys.* 328 (2014) 1079–1115. - João, Anđelković, Covaci, Rappoport, Lopes and Ferreira, KITE, [*Royal Society Open Science* 7:191809 (2020)](https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.191809). - Arb/FLINT for the interval arithmetic behind the certificates. - Anthropic Economics, [AI for scientific discovery: how researchers use Claude](https://www.anthropic.com/research/how-researchers-use-claude), November 5, 2026 — physics and astronomy at 40% of researcher time, against 32% for biology.