{ "schema": "diophantine-negative-results/v70", "date": "2026-11-17", "scope": "Proved obstructions and lower bounds under their explicitly stated hypotheses. No global variable minimum or number-field counterexample is asserted.", "origin": "Historical theorem records separated from data/results.json, with additional proved obstruction records. The complete manuscript index is negative_results/README.md.", "theorems": [ { "id": "degree_and_coordinate_lower_bounds", "minimum_total_degree_single_equation": 4, "minimum_total_coordinates": 3, "minimum_total_coordinates_quadratic_or_cubic_systems": 4, "individual_degree_lower_bound": 2, "scope": "Infinite input projections contained in O_K,S, for every number field K and finite S. The coordinate bounds also allow open conditions and finite alternatives. Individual-degree bounds concern essential coordinates of a single defining polynomial.", "three_coordinate_system_theorem": "The equations must have a common irreducible factor of total degree at least four.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/lower_bounds/lower_bounds_20261109_v15.tex", "minimum_total_coordinates_quadratic_systems": 5, "minimum_total_coordinates_nonnegative_quartics": 5, "minimum_degree_nonnegative_three_coordinate_polynomial": 8, "sharp_coordinate_minimum_known": false, "nonnegative_scope": "Globally nonnegative at one real embedding; includes all sums of squares. This does not exclude sign-changing quartics in three or four coordinates.", "three_coordinate_quartic_constraints": "Absolutely irreducible, dense smooth rational points, and sign-changing." }, { "id": "field_extension_obstruction", "scope": "No one unchanged existential formula defines rings of integers in every finite extension; a different formula for each field is not excluded.", "explicit_quartic_counterexample": { "input": "1/2", "nonzero_witness_coordinate": 293, "specialization": "P392((1/2)e1+Y e293)=Y^2+D/16", "field": "Q(sqrt(-D))", "D": "16*P392((1/2)e1)>0", "data": "computation/quartic/final392/field-specialization392.json" }, "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/unchanged_formula_obstruction_20261116_v42.tex" }, { "id": "elliptic_point_charts", "minimum_retained_parameters": 2, "scope": "Finite algebraic presentations of an infinite set of points of the specified elliptic curve over Q(sqrt(2)); not a general lower bound for defining Z.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/elliptic_chart_obstruction_20261107_v7.tex" }, { "id": "scalar_height_degree_threshold", "minimum_degree": 4, "scope": "For every number field F, no rational function A/B of two variables with max(deg A,deg B)<=3 is finite-to-one on the F-points of any nonempty archimedean open set. Some fiber there is infinite with unbounded height.", "sharp_example": "U^4-delta*V^4 for delta in F not a fourth power has finite F-fibers.", "scope_limit": "Ambient pairs only; not a lower bound on the coordinates of a Diophantine definition or on measurements of restricted elliptic multiples.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/scalar_heights/cubic_scalar_height_obstruction_20261109_v11.tex" }, { "id": "norm_trace_graph_obstruction", "statement": "Norm and trace graphs are Zariski dense in the affine plane over L, so have no quantifier-free definitions.", "scope": "Proper finite extensions of characteristic-zero fields; the obstruction concerns quantifier-free definitions, not existential definitions.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/norm_trace_graph_obstruction_20261116_v42.tex" }, { "id": "finite_collection_formula_obstruction", "statement": "Any fixed finite collection of existential formulas with infinite input projections over a number field simultaneously accepts some rational noninteger in a finite Galois extension of bounded degree.", "scope_limit": "No actual counterexample to a separately chosen defining polynomial for each field is established.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/unchanged_formula_obstruction_20261116_v42.tex" }, { "id": "abscissa_multiplicative_obstruction", "general_statement": "For y^2=x^3+A*x+B over Q, if A,B are p-integral and B is a nonzero nonsquare modulo an odd prime p, every rational abscissa has even p-adic valuation.", "example": "E:y^2=x^3-2 has the infinite-order point (3,5), but 5 is not in the multiplicative subgroup generated by its rational abscissas.", "exact_point_counts": { "5": 6, "7": 7 }, "scope_limit": "This does not obstruct sums, more elaborate definitions, or definability of a ring of integers in its field.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/abscissa_product_obstruction_20261116_v42.tex" }, { "id": "quadratic_input_map_obstruction", "contact_polynomial": "r(T)=T*(T-1)*(T-2401)*(32*T+343)*(2*T-1)", "statement": "No q in Z[X] of degree at most two simultaneously reflects rational integrality, is odd at every integer, and has r(q(x)) square in Q_2 at every integer.", "quadratic_classification": "A*X^2+B*X+C with A nonzero reflects integrality if and only if |A| is squarefree and A divides B.", "positive_map_minimum_degree": 4, "positive_examples": [ "8*X^4+3", "8*X^4+2403" ], "scope_limit": "Only this odd-valued, uncorrected contact-square normalization; not corrected or parity-free routes and not a lower bound for arbitrary defining polynomials.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/input_normalization/quadratic_input_obstruction_20261109_v12.tex", "verification": "computation/input_normalization/quadratic-input-obstruction-certificate.json" }, { "id": "locally_dense_proper_rational_subset", "polynomial": "T*((U^2*W-9*W^3-1)^2-2*(V^2*T*W-9*T^3*W^3-1)^2)", "quadratic_fields_d": [ -15, -13, -11, -10, -1, 3, 5, 7 ], "statement": "In every listedQ(sqrt(d)), the projection is the same proper subsetD ofQ containing0,1 and excluding-1.", "local_statement": "D is simultaneously dense in every finite product ofQ-completions; every local input has witnesses in every completion of each listed quadratic field.", "total_coordinates": 4, "degree": 13, "coefficient_height": 162, "monomials": 11, "rank_verification": "UnconditionalPARI ellrank bounds, with torsion and exact point calculations.", "scope_limit": "Not a definition ofZ,Q,or a ring of integers, and not a counterexample to existence of a different definition.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/elliptic_ratios_and_integrality_20261109_v13.tex", "verification": "computation/number_fields/elliptic-ratio-certificate.json" }, { "id": "elliptic_witness_structural_constraints", "finite_presentation_bound": "Recovering arbitrary tuples of r independent points in the specified simple Weil restriction by finite algebraic choices requires at least2r retained rational coordinates.", "index_graph": "For a Zariski-dense cyclic subgroup of an abelian variety, the graph {(n,[n]P)} is Zariski dense in G_a times that variety.", "rational_curve_obstruction": "The paired formal requirements H=[h]P at one split place and H-P at the other cannot hold for arbitrarily many good primes when E and P are rational.", "two_curve_scope": "A curve correspondence containing a common-index graph yields an isogeny and prevents infinitely many coprime reduction orders.", "scope_limit": "Restrictions on these specified compression mechanisms, not universal lower bounds for integer-defining polynomials.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/structural_constraints_20261109_v13.tex", "verification": "computation/elliptic_constraints/large-split-order-certificate.json", "large_prime_parity_counterexample": { "prime": 77017, "above_cutoff": 76176, "sqrt2_residues": [ 18810, 58207 ], "exact_orders": [ 2141, 2405 ], "odd_common_index": 5149105, "congruences": "p=1 mod8 and p=3 mod7", "scope": "These congruences alone; the full Gaussian-generator and avoidance conditions are not asserted." } }, { "id": "finite_rational_images_of_abelian_points_omit_integers", "statement": "Every finite union of fixed rational-function images on finite products of fixed abelian varieties over a number field, even with finitely many values added, misses infinitely many rational integers.", "source": "Corvaja and Zannier, arXiv:2608.28255v1, Theorem1.1; Mordell-Weil finite generation.", "consequence": "Finite rational operations on the specified stable-elliptic subsets cannot produce a set containing every integer.", "scope_limit": "Does not cover arbitrary algebraic correspondences or unrestricted affine witnesses. Not a nondefinability theorem for rings of integers.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/elliptic_ratios_and_integrality_20261109_v13.tex" }, { "id": "slope_ratio_proper_rational_subset", "polynomial": "T*((T^2*Z^2*W-9*W^3-1)^2-2*(Z^2*S-9*S^3-1)^2)", "quadratic_fields_d": [ -15, -13, -11, -10, -1, 3, 5, 7 ], "total_coordinates": 4, "degree": 11, "coefficient_height": 162, "monomials": 11, "statement": "The projection in each specified quadratic field is zero together with ratios of nonzero rational elliptic slopes; it misses infinitely many rational integers.", "scope_limit": "Not a definition of the rational subfield or a ring of integers. The bounded search does not certify particular omitted values.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/elliptic_ratios_and_integrality_20261109_v13.tex", "verification": "computation/number_fields/rationality-filter-certificate.json" }, { "id": "finite_correspondences_over_abelian_varieties", "statement": "For a variety mapping to an abelian variety, if each geometric fiber has only finitely many output values, its rational outputs meet every finitely generated multiplicative subgroup in a finite set.", "includes": "Quasi-finite covers and affine translates of multiplicative subgroups; generic finiteness alone requires exceptional fibers to be treated separately.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/finite_correspondences_and_denominators_20261109_v14.tex", "exceptional_surface_verification": "computation/number_fields/exceptional-correspondence-certificate.json" }, { "id": "bounded_denominator_fiber_obstructions", "statement": "Over an abelian base, bounded-denominator outputs with soluble unirational fibers or smooth proper genus-one fibers equipped with an ample line bundle cannot cover all integers.", "genus_one_inputs": [ "Siegel", "uniform torsion", "finite map to the relative Jacobian", "semiabelian Mordell-Lang" ], "scope_limit": "No obstruction for all higher-genus families, and no counterexample to general ring-of-integers definability.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/finite_correspondences_and_denominators_20261109_v14.tex" }, { "id": "constant_pole_parameter_obstruction", "statement": "No fixed rational value of the parameter e gives the complete stated zero-preparation pole certificate.", "exceptional_parameters": [ "-1/3", "1" ], "prepared_counterexample": "b=(204/55)^2", "exact_rank_bounds": [ [ 0, 0 ], [ 1, 1 ] ], "conditional_on_BSD": false, "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/fixed_pole_parameters_20261109_v17.tex", "verification": "computation/pole_parameters/fixed-e-obstruction-certificate.json", "additional_retained_chart_obstructions": { "tau=+/-1": "b=(204/61)^2", "tau=+/-17": "b=(204/101)^2" }, "retained_chart_verifications": [ "computation/pole_parameters/fixed-tau-one-obstruction.json", "computation/pole_parameters/fixed-tau17-obstruction.json", "computation/pole_parameters/small-fixed-tau17-obstruction.json" ], "scope_limit": "These counterexamples range over prepared inputs. They do not exclude a fixed retained parameter on a specially selected prime-pattern subfamily.", "dense_prepared_counterexamples": "For tau=+/-17, counterexamples are dense in every real subinterval of (0,17), with valuations4,2,2 at2,3,17." }, { "id": "combining_pole_certificates_obstructions", "statement": "Two explicit prepared inputs cannot share an actual pole parameter; symmetric contact products can have odd radical one at unbounded scale height.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/combining_pole_certificates_20261109_v16.tex", "verification": "computation/pole_parameters/pole-merger-obstructions.json", "scope_limit": "Obstructions to specified simplifications, not general coordinate lower bounds." }, { "id": "restricted_abc_applicability_obstructions", "statement": "The natural even-power Frey family has exponential growth of the reduced j denominator in logarithmic height. Infinitely many required integer witnesses fail the fixed asymmetric-size hypotheses.", "frey_denominator_lower_bound": "max(|A|,|B|)^(4*d)/256 for coprime nonzero A,B and positive even d", "frey_j_height_upper_bound": "6*d*log(max(|A|,|B|))+log(6912)", "proof": "negative_results/papers/restricted_abc/restricted_abc_inputs_20261109_v17.tex", "verification": "computation/restricted_abc/frey-denominator-certificate.json", "scope_limit": "Applicability obstruction for the specified families; neither disproves abc nor excludes other families." }, { "id": "six_contact_product_cancellation", "statement": "For every rational a>4, lambda=-(a+1)/(5a) gives a negative nonzero square R(lambda)R(a*lambda), hence odd radical one. This applies to the source scales a=beta^8+T(n)^8. Positive unbounded-scale examples and the full twelve-element contact automorphism group are also proved.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/product_height_obstructions_20261110_v19.tex", "verification": "computation/pole_parameters/product-height-obstructions-v19-certificate.json", "scope_limit": "The fixed product alone cannot support a uniform height bound. These examples do not satisfy all the other elliptic and pole constraints automatically; no counterexample to the 13-variable theorem is claimed." }, { "id": "complex_multiplication_and_trace_cancellation", "scope": "For every number field K with i not in K and every D in K*, with E_D:y^2=x^3-D*x and L=K(i).", "rank_formula": "rank E_D(L)=2 rank E_D(K)", "trace_statement": "For a nontorsion P in E_D(K), C=(1+iota)P has Tr_L/K x([n]C)=Tr_L/Q x([n]C)=0 for all nonzero n, while h(x([n]C))=4*n^2*hat_h(P)+O_E(1).", "sum_statement": "The four distinct doubled points [2n]P, iota[2n]P, [4n]P, iota[4n]P have distinct abscissas summing to zero and unbounded heights.", "explicit_field": "Q(sqrt(2),i)", "explicit_nontorsion_certificate": "Reduction orders5 and3 at primes17 and23; group orders20 and24 exclude torsion.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/complex_multiplication_and_trace_cancellation_20261110_v19.tex", "verification": "computation/number_fields/trace-cancellation-certificate.json", "scope_limit": "An obstruction to extending the particular elliptic group and height mechanism; no counterexample to Diophantine definability of O_L in L is claimed." }, { "id": "rational_function_contact_parity", "fixed_parameters": "Odd integer B>=3, nonzero integer n, rational T>6; beta(X)=2*X^2+B; a(X)=beta(X)^8+T^8.", "statement": "For every nonzero Psi in Q(X,lambda), there are a fixed positive cone of contact depths, a nonzero parity class, and infinitely many good primes such that every positive depth pair in that cone and parity class is realized by half-integral X and lambda=s^2+t^2>1 with integers s,t. The two contact values have those depths, Psi is defined and nonzero with even valuation, and beta(X)-n is a p-unit.", "scope": "No additional arithmetic conjecture; includes explicit rational dependence on the input and scale. The source specialization T=Tr(x([n]P)) is covered whenever T>6.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/rational_combinations_of_contacts_20261110_v20.tex", "verification": "computation/pole_parameters/rational-contact-combination-examples-v20.json", "checker": "computation/pole_parameters/check_rational_contact_combinations_v20.py", "computation_scope": "Two exact illustrative examples, independently checked by BigInt integer arithmetic and Fraction rational arithmetic; the universal statement is a formal-series and prime-existence proof.", "scope_limit": "An obstruction to one rational function uniformly detecting the union of two odd contact valuations; no false solution of the complete Diophantine source and no absolute variable-count lower bound are asserted.", "pdf_available": true, "stronger_slope_restriction": "The same conclusions hold with lambda=1+s^2 for a nonzero integer s; lambda-1 is an integer square.", "pdf": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/rational_combinations_of_contacts_20261110_v20.pdf" }, { "id": "quadratic_contact_cover_obstructions", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/quadratic_contact_covers_20261110_v21.tex", "pdf": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/quadratic_contact_covers_20261110_v21.pdf", "certificate": "computation/pole_parameters/quadratic-contact-covers-certificate.json", "product_cover_genus": 4, "scale_domain": "Every rational a>4", "single_contact_cover_genus": 2, "finiteness": "At each fixed scale and finite prime set, only finitely many admissible rational slopes have equal odd contact sets.", "section_obstruction_prime": 315467, "section_obstruction_shifts": "B=3+k*62790389880761304, k>=0, at integer input X=0", "scope": "Genus, finiteness and the inert-prime comparison obstruction are unconditional. The separately stated one-pole soundness implication retains weak abc and the original arithmetic premises; its converse is open. No new defining variable count." }, { "id": "index_products_and_finite_correspondences", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/index_products_and_finite_correspondences_20261110_v21.tex", "pdf": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/index_products_and_finite_correspondences_20261110_v21.pdf", "statement": "If ZP is Zariski dense in an abelian variety A, the triples ([n]P,[h]P,[nh]P) are Zariski dense in A^3 for any infinite set of n and any infinite set of h for each n.", "elliptic_proof": "An elementary intersection-degree argument using graphs of multiplication.", "general_proof": "Mordell-Lang gives a density criterion in terms of finite unions of rational affine hyperplanes in the index lattice.", "consequence": "No fixed algebraic correspondence with finite geometric fibers can recover the index product uniformly on those pairs; nonlinear polynomial index graphs satisfy the analogous obstruction.", "scope": "No claim about arbitrary Diophantine definitions, additional free parameters, positive-dimensional fibers with finite rational point sets, or specially selected finite sets of auxiliary indices." }, { "id": "four_contact_bounded_odd_radical_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/contact_heights/four_contact_radical_obstruction_20261116_v42.tex", "verification": "computation/contact_heights/input-height-amplification-certificate.json", "statement": "For the contacts {-1,0,2,3}, infinitely many rational t have unbounded logarithmic height and odd contact radical one outside {2,3,5}; the points can be chosen with 3=1, the prepared b_m=409*(204/1013^m)^2 gives no Q_1013-point on Y^2=1+b_m*(1+b_m*v^2)^2, including on its smooth projective model.", "scope_limit": "This disproves completeness on all prepared inputs even for a finite disjunction of fixed nonzero kappa values; the restricted comparison-prime family remains unresolved. No variable-count improvement follows.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/quartic_pole_obstruction_20261109_v17.tex", "verification": "computation/pole_parameters/quartic-pole-obstruction.json", "general_obstruction": "For every finite fixed set C of nonzero rational kappa, infinitely many prepared b tending to zero make all the corresponding smooth quartic curves locally insoluble at one prime." }, { "id": "mixed_reference_signs", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/mixed_reference_signs_20261116_v42.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/mixed_sign_v42/certificate.json", "statement": "For H_j=[28101000+30510750j]P, j>=0, H_j reduces to O at (76537,sqrt(2)-26935) and H_j-P reduces to T0 at (76537,sqrt(2)-49602). All H_j belong to 2E(K) and satisfy the characteristic-zero reference-chart open conditions.", "scope": "Automatic agreement of torsion-translation signs cannot be deduced from the reference chart and doubling alone; no full detector counterexample is asserted." }, { "id": "fixed_input_k3_geometry", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/fixed_input_k3_surfaces_20261116_v42.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/fixed_input_k3_v42/verification.json", "statement": "For nonzero C,D in characteristic zero, the pole surface with conic parameter variable resolves to a K3 surface. Its double-cover model has four A3 singularities. The component of a finite common-parameter product dominating the parameter line has no rationally connected smooth projective model.", "scope": "Fixed detector inputs only. No obstruction to rational points, common rational parameters, or constructions varying the auxiliary indices is asserted." }, { "id": "rational_section_classification", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/rational_sections_20261116_v42.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/rational_sections_v42/verification.json", "assumptions": "C,D nonzero rational; tau transcendental; e=(tau^2-D)/(tau^2+3D).", "affine_criterion": "q^2=D(s^2-Ce)(s^2+3Ce) has s,q in Q(tau) iff C or -3D is a rational square.", "projective_criterion": "The smooth projective generic fiber has a Q(tau)-point iff at least one of C,D,-3D is a rational square.", "prepared_criterion": "For prepared b=d*a^2, D=17d and C=17(17-b), a section exists iff C is a rational square.", "explicit_section_when_C_is_square": "C=c^2: s=c and q=-4CD*tau/(tau^2+3D).", "scope": "A section obstruction, not nonexistence of specialized rational fibers, common rational parameters, multisections, or actual variable-input constructions." }, { "id": "actual_square_complement_return_neighborhoods", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/actual_square_complement_neighborhoods_20261116_v43.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/actual_square_complement_v43/verification.json", "statement": "For every odd L>=3 in the original general source, some X in {3,6,7} has nonsquare-unit baseline complement modulo 23. Actual prepared guarded tuples and independent-index return families can keep all detector inputs in that nonsquare-complement neighborhood.", "scope_limit": "This excludes global square complements on those particular legitimate families, not on all source choices. It does not obstruct common rational fibers without sections." }, { "id": "square_complement_normalization_destroys_pole_predicate", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/square_complement_normalization_20261116_v43.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/square_complement_normalization_v43/verification.json", "normalization": "Phi(b)=1156*b/(17+b)^2", "counterfamily": "b_n=204^2/409^(2n-1), n>=2", "statement": "The original pole curves have no Q_409-point for any local conic parameter, whereas the normalized prepared input has a rational square complement and an explicit nonzero rational pole section. The square class is preserved.", "scope_limit": "A counterexample to replacing the final pole input by Phi(b), not a false solution of the complete detector source and not an objection to separately proved early-scalar changes." }, { "id": "shared_reference_test_cancellations", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/shared_reference_test_obstructions_20261116_v43.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/shared_reference_tests_v43/verification.json", "statement": "The stated squared reference factor admits exact cancellation at the specified split prime. Both whole-factor odd-cube repairs have local zeros, and arbitrarily high nonzero valuations, while the comparison error is a unit. The actual contact function has a local inverse realizing the required parameter.", "prime": 76537, "scope_limit": "Local factor-level implications only. No simultaneous global, cyclic, doubled, two-detector or full-source counterexample is asserted." }, { "id": "fixed_class_synchronization_and_common_parameter_geometry", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/fixed_class_synchronization_20261116_v43.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/fixed_class_synchronization_v43/certificate.json", "assumptions": "Distinct positive rational D_i and fixed nonzero rational twist classes alpha_i; nonzero C_i for the full common-pole variety.", "propagation_curve_genus": "1+2^r*(r-1)", "two_pole_jacobian_factor_dimensions": [ 1, 1, 1, 2 ], "statement": "Each fixed class tuple permits only finitely many rational parameters when r>=2. The rational-Mobius two-pole genus remains five when D_1/D_2 is nonsquare. A smooth proper model of the full common-pole variety has omega_X=f^*O(2r-2), hence Kodaira dimension one for r>=2 and cannot be birational to a finite quotient of an abelian variety.", "scope_limit": "No obstruction to one common rational fiber or the infinite union over varying classes. Direct Kummer-quotient methods are excluded for this variety, not every possible reformulation." }, { "id": "native_poles_over_abelian_parameter_spaces", "proof": "negative_results/papers/rational_fibers/abelian_parameter_obstruction_20261116_v44.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/abelian_parameter_v44/certificate.json", "assumptions": "Fixed source input and nonzero early scalar; an abelian parameter variety over Q; native point roles given by rational maps; all generic source guards nonzero; nonconstant detector argument.", "statement": "For the native ten-contact general and six-contact conditional detectors, the square complement is not a rational function-field square and the original normalized pole equations have no rational function-field witness, even with varying twist-class representative and all projective conic parameters.", "proof_method": "Q-simplicity of Res(E), codimension-two fibers of the reference map, an odd contact divisor forced by an etale-cover and higher-genus contradiction, and a universal negative-odd-valuation pole obstruction.", "scope_limit": "No exclusion of fixed-argument rational incidence lifts, individual arithmetic tuples, ramified covers, or all possible smaller Diophantine definitions. No 24-variable completeness theorem is established." }, { "id": "opposite_reference_signs_after_duplication", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/duplicated_reference_signs_20261116_v44.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/duplicated_sign_v44/verification.json", "statement": "The allowed global reference progression H_j=[10435875+61021500j]R0, P=2R0, has [2]H_j formal at the first place above 76537 and [2](H_j-P) in the T0 neighborhood at the other, producing opposite translation signs.", "index_domain": "All allowed source points, including half-integral indices relative to P.", "prime": 76537, "embeddings": [ 26935, 49602 ], "reduced_R0_orders": [ 6375, 9572 ], "finite_field_order_four_point": [ 35686, 1608 ], "finite_field_half": [ 24152, 13484 ], "scope_limit": "The reference domain and admissible soundness contact primes do not ensure agreement of doubled signs. No complete detector or nonintegral defining-polynomial witness is asserted." }, { "id": "fixed_argument_native_complement_ramification", "proof": "negative_results/papers/rational_fibers/fixed_argument_complement_ramification_20261116_v44.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/fixed_argument_complement_v44/certificate.json", "assumptions": "Fixed allowed native input, slope, scales and root points, positive detector coefficient w, and the full independent auxiliary product (Res E)^5 or (Res E)^2 with generic source guards.", "statement": "The square-complement double cover is geometrically ramified. It cannot acquire a rational section under a surjective translated homomorphism of abelian varieties, including all isogenies and the independent half-point doubling map.", "proof_method": "Restriction to U_A^-=T0 leaves a moving elliptic function with pole divisor 4(T0+T++T\u2212); only finitely many such functions can have an unramified normalized complement cover. Smooth surjective pullback preserves odd divisor multiplicities.", "scope_limit": "This is a uniform-section obstruction on the full product. It does not exclude proper lower-dimensional coupled subvarieties, individually chosen rational points, or common rational pole fibers without square complements. No new variable lower bound or 24-variable completeness theorem." }, { "id": "signed_finite_class_native_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/finite_nonsquare_class_obstruction_20261116_v47.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/finite_nonsquare_classes_v47/certificate.json", "scope": "Every finite set of nontrivial signed rational square classes for the original general scalar; arbitrary guarded rational source tuples and all nonzero rational m in levels17m^2; uniform in odd L.", "rational_square_class_excluded_from_obstruction": true, "redesigned_norm_scalar_excluded_from_obstruction": true, "global_variable_minimum_established": false }, { "id": "automatic_native_level_finiteness", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/automatic_level_finiteness_20261116_v48.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/automatic_levels_v48/certificate.json", "sources": "The original six-factor weak-abc and ordinary-abc native detectors", "level": "a=w*Norm(W)", "valuation_bound": "v_p(Norm(W))<=-2*nu and v_p(a)<=-nu when v_p(w)=nu>0 is odd outside S", "auxiliary_scope": "Every guarded tuple; split and inert primes; no square-norm assumption", "finiteness_method": "Finite exceptional square classes and Faltings on genus-two twists of the six-contact polynomial", "consequence": "Finitely many integer inputs for fixed B; no rational input for sufficiently large B; fixed finite rational rescalings do not repair uniform completeness", "scope": "The automatic-level method only. No obstruction to bounded norm levels, different scalars, individual compatible tuples, or all Diophantine definitions.", "global_variable_minimum_established": false }, { "id": "complete_tangent_quadratic_identity_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/tangent_completion_20261116_v48.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/tangent_completion_v48/certificate.json", "independent_certificate": "negative_results/computation/tangent_completion_v48/independent-verification.json", "trace_certificate": "negative_results/computation/tangent_completion_v48/trace-certificate.json", "trace_independent_certificate": "negative_results/computation/tangent_completion_v48/trace-independent-verification.json", "field_coordinates": 10, "field_quadratic_identity_dimension": 19, "field_monomials": 66, "field_evaluation_rank": 47, "rational_coordinates_with_trace": 21, "rational_monomials_with_trace": 253, "rational_quadratic_identity_dimension_with_trace": 59, "rational_evaluation_rank_with_trace": 194, "characteristic_zero_proof": "Monic Laurent normal forms lift the certified modular ranks; explicit spanning identities vanish on the entire false family", "consequence": "Every quadratic identity of the specified embedding, including rational conjugate products and the physical trace, vanishes on a false tangent family with arbitrary trace", "scope": "No statement about different embeddings, additional helpers, identities required only on a restricted arithmetic family, or a global variable minimum.", "global_variable_minimum_established": false }, { "id": "affine_scalar_coupling_v50", "statement": "Every fixed finite set of affine identifications S=[m]A+[k]P excludes an infinite arithmetic progression of integer inputs in the specified general source.", "scope": "Original beta=216X^4+450459 and scalar rho, throughout the sufficiently large coefficient range where n=beta. All original guards and arithmetic premises retained.", "proof": "negative_results/papers/integer_labels/affine_scalar_coupling_obstruction_20261116_v50.tex", "verification": "negative_results/computation/affine_coupling_v50/affine_coupling_certificate.json", "counterexample": { "m": 1, "k": 2, "X": 11, "p": 80287, "rho_valuation": 1, "required_scalar_index_minus_one_valuation": 3, "actual_valuation": 0 }, "global_minimum_claimed": false }, { "id": "fixed_native_traces_v51", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/fixed_trace_obstructions_20261116_v51.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/fixed_traces_v51/certificate.json", "conditional_certificate": "negative_results/computation/fixed_traces_v51/chamber_certificate.json", "original_general_source": { "input": 4, "prime": 252877, "prime_square": 63946777129, "rho_valuation": 1, "inert_reciprocal_trace_residues": [ 0, 2 ], "all_guarded_slopes_and_tuples": true, "all_odd_L": true, "unit_trace_obstructed": true, "any_finite_fixed_trace_menu_uniformly_obstructed": true }, "conditional_source": { "unit_trace_real_roots_on_t_greater_than_1": 1, "two_coupled_unit_traces_on_that_interval": false, "other_real_intervals_excluded": true, "unit_trace_real_roots_on_t_less_than_minus_1": 1, "all_slope_scope": "Actual prepared tuples with source shift B>=19; only simultaneous unit trace is excluded.", "necessary_scale_strict_upper_bound": 147456, "negative_argument_scale_strict_upper_bound": 80, "source_shift_threshold": 19 }, "scope": "Fixed trace targets only. The varying prescribed-trace norm equations and modified scalar sources remain open.", "global_variable_minimum_established": false, "conditional_scale_certificates": [ "negative_results/computation/fixed_traces_v51/positive_scale_certificate.json", "negative_results/computation/fixed_traces_v51/negative_scale_certificate.json" ] }, { "id": "fixed_native_square_fibers_v53", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/fixed_flat_fibers_20261116_v53.tex", "certificate": "negative_results/computation/fixed_flat_fibers_v53/certificate.json", "input_values": [ 1, 2 ], "auxiliary_index": 3, "coefficient_shift_fixture": 3, "height_exponent": 4, "single_cover_genera": [ 59, 83 ], "simultaneous_cover_genera": [ 236, 332 ], "rational_boundary_points": 4, "comparisons": [ "original", "symmetric" ], "geometrically_integral": true, "finite_rational_point_nonexistence_proved": false, "varying_auxiliary_indices_excluded": false, "global_variable_minimum_established": false, "scope": "The specified actual fixed fibers only; B=3 is not asserted sufficient for a defining construction." }, { "id": "deterministic_order_three_inert_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/order_three_inert_obstruction_20261117_v56.tex", "verification": "negative_results/computation/order_three_v56/certificate.json", "prime": 81421, "covered_shift_residues": 81421, "certificate_rows": 13, "root_point": "A=[X]P", "scope": "Every positive odd B has infinitely many positive input failures for the specified deterministic height substitution and either stated detector weight, uniformly in all auxiliary tuples.", "other_couplings_excluded": false }, { "id": "rational_conditional_detector_products", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/rational_detector_products_20261117_v56.tex", "scope": "An actual rational conditional product W with the pole implication has no nonexceptional odd contact; both rational products permit only finitely many integer inputs.", "arithmetic_input": "Faltings theorem for fixed genus-two twists", "nonrational_products_excluded": false, "general_source_excluded": false }, { "id": "intrinsic_specializations", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/intrinsic_specializations_20261117_v57.tex", "scope": "Finite rational-function menus for s(d), and positive abscissa classes on rank-one congruent curves; adaptive relations and higher rank remain outside the result.", "proved": true }, { "id": "prepared_sha_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/prepared_sha_obstruction_20261117_v57.tex", "prepared_input": "112/225", "everywhere_locally_soluble": true, "has_rational_point": false, "scope": "The q0=0 one-coordinate specialization on prepared inputs; no assertion that the input is an actual detector tuple.", "proved": true }, { "id": "actual_multiplication_surface", "proof": "negative_results/papers/rational_fibers/actual_multiplication_surface_20261117_v58.tex", "scope": "No uniform square identity for nonconstant rational slope on the full fixed-index multiplication surface. Individual witnesses, constant slopes, proper subfamilies and ramified covers remain open.", "individual_rational_witness_nonexistence_claimed": false }, { "id": "two_square_height", "proof": "negative_results/papers/contact_heights/two_square_height_20261117_v58.tex", "scope": "Fixed-output, unbounded-height families for every power-of-two exponent. The actual inner source form is not imposed.", "actual_detector_counterexample_claimed": false }, { "id": "fixed_slope_trace_finiteness", "proof": "negative_results/papers/rational_fibers/fixed_slope_trace_finiteness_20261117_v59.tex", "scope": "Fixed input, prepared slope, positive first block of the stated reweighted sources, and fixed smooth genus-one trace curve. All independent point roles may vary.", "individual_witnesses_excluded": false, "variable_slope_excluded": false, "untwisted_conic_excluded": false, "derivative_source_transfer_asserted": false }, { "id": "denominator_support_height_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/denominator_support_height_obstruction_20261117_v60.tex", "scope": "Positive odd contact support in the denominator of H, uniform radical and height bounds, and a fixed rational carrier generically nonconstant in U. Guard-free finiteness concerns intended X=n, U=[n]H witnesses.", "all_two_point_sources_excluded": false, "all_nine_variable_sources_excluded": false, "nondegeneracy_guard_required_for_intended_finiteness": false, "siegel_used": true }, { "id": "square_rescaled_weight_perturbation", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/square_rescaled_weight_perturbation_20261117_v60.tex", "scope": "Fixed elliptic points, input-independent weight square class, rational balanced tests, and strict preparation; no additional closed equation restricting the input.", "all_nine_variable_sources_excluded": false }, { "id": "input_only_weight_false_witnesses", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/input_only_weight_false_witnesses_20261117_v61.tex", "scope": "The stated amplified index block plus the explicit degree-eight input-only weight. Every X=2+1/q outside a fixed finite set has complete rational witnesses under the retained intrinsic-pole theorem.", "input_height_upper_bound_proved_under_abc": true, "external_input_equality_proved": false, "all_two_point_sources_excluded": false, "all_nine_variable_sources_excluded": false, "global_witness_existence_is_a_theorem": true, "global_witnesses_numerically_computed": false }, { "id": "six_contact_mobius_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/six_contact_mobius_obstruction_20261117_v62.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/six_contact_mobius_v62", "scope": "The displayed six-contact source, prescribed root A=P at input X=1, exponents4 and6, and eventual completeness for every sufficiently large odd coefficient shift.", "symmetry_count": 12, "uniform_rational_square_gap_branches": 10, "inert_prime": 76253, "all_finite_exceptional_sets": true, "uses_chebotarev": true, "all_fixed_shifts_excluded": false, "variable_nonunit_rescalings_excluded": false, "derivative_detector_excluded": false, "all_nine_variable_sources_excluded": false }, { "id": "six_contact_mobius_all_integer_powers", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/six_contact_mobius_obstruction_20261117_v63.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/six_contact_mobius_v63", "scope": "The displayed six-contact source, prescribed X=1 and A=P, every fixed integer exponent at least4, and every fixed finite menu of such exponents; failure of eventual completeness over sufficiently large odd shifts.", "symmetry_count": 12, "uniform_rational_square_gap_branches": 10, "all_integer_exponents_at_least_four": true, "simultaneous_fixed_finite_exponent_menus": true, "fixed_finite_rational_multiplier_menus": true, "all_finite_exceptional_sets": true, "uses_chebotarev": true, "all_fixed_shifts_excluded": false, "variable_nonunit_rescalings_excluded": false, "derivative_detector_excluded": false, "all_nine_variable_sources_excluded": false }, { "id": "rank_stable_adjacent_contacts", "proof": "negative_results/papers/number_fields/rank_stable_adjacent_contacts_20261117_v63.tex", "scope": "A fixed non-torsion elliptic point descends after multiplication; two identity contacts with a fixed nonzero index difference at places above the same good base prime.", "arbitrary_finite_extensions": true, "torsion_translates": true, "ramified_places_allowed": true, "residue_characteristic_dividing_multiplier_allowed": true, "finite_index_shift_menus": true, "all_local_detector_architectures_excluded": false, "number_field_counterexample": false }, { "id": "cofinite_mobius_coupling_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/cofinite_mobius_coupling_obstruction_20261117_v64.tex", "scope": "The exact-root six-contact source and every fixed B in the stated obstructed progression; finite integer exponent and rational multiplier menus.", "infinite_positive_input_progression": true, "common_input_progression_after_coefficient_refinement": true, "finite_input_repairs_excluded": true, "exact_root_prescription": "A=[n]P at X=n", "unspecified_torsion_translates_excluded": false, "all_fixed_coefficient_shifts_excluded": false, "all_nine_variable_sources_excluded": false }, { "id": "derivative_actual_trace_genus", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/derivative_trace_genus_20261117_v65.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/derivative_trace_genus_v65", "scope": "The specified nine-shift derivative detector with a>10 and four nonzero finite tests in each slot; actual guarded multiplication locus A=[n]P, U=[n]H.", "simple_rational_branch_contacts": 18, "minimum_geometric_genus": 8, "weight_contact_derivatives": [ -18, 18 ], "radicand_contact_derivatives": [ -36, 36 ], "geometric_rational_curves_on_guarded_multiplication_locus": false, "known_branch_points_satisfy_weight_guard": false, "actual_trace_realization_disproved": false, "nine_variable_definition_excluded": false, "number_field_counterexample": false }, { "id": "quadratic_point_role_restrictions", "proof": "negative_results/papers/integer_labels/point_role_restrictions_20261117_v66.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/point_roles_v66", "scope": "Retained original general source with n=216X^4+450459; fixed sufficiently large coefficient exponent. Quadratic root restrictions concern every source witness; group-word and cross-root restrictions concern exact multiplication witnesses only.", "root_relation_degree_at_most": 2, "finite_relation_menus": true, "infinite_positive_omissions_in_every_fixed_progression": true, "independent_group_words_per_pair": 2, "finite_menus_of_group_word_pairs": true, "order_of_index_choices_unrestricted_for_two_word_obstruction": true, "arbitrary_numerator_index_families_excluded": false, "all_twenty_one_variable_definitions_excluded": false, "shifted_single_coupling_completeness_proved": false }, { "id": "physical_detector_Laurent_scaling", "proof": "negative_results/papers/quartic/physical_detector_scaling_20261117_v67.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/physical_detector_scaling_v67", "scope": "The displayed shared special-factor allocation or one literal rational reference row with three specified physical field factors. Only diagonal Laurent coordinate changes and monomial row division, with either stated five-coordinate unit basis.", "physical_contacts": { "q0": "u=x77", "q1": "u*v=x77*x90" }, "unbounded_real_weights": true, "shared_factor_forced_difference": [ 0, -3 ], "four_row_forced_weight_difference": 12, "four_row_allowed_upper_bounds": { "original_units": 6, "modified_units": 2 }, "exact_Farkas_rhs": { "original_units": -12, "modified_units": -20 }, "full_square_terms_force_common_component_row_multipliers": true, "arbitrary_factor_pairings_excluded": false, "row_combinations_excluded": false, "general_variable_lower_bound": false, "new_defining_polynomial_count": false }, { "id": "actual_trace_curves_and_abelian_families", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/curves_and_abelian_families_20261117_v69.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/actual_trace_curves_v69", "fixed_rational_input": true, "all_point_roles_independent": true, "each_fixed_curve_has_finitely_many_rational_points": true, "genus_zero_or_one_Q_curves_excluded": true, "derivative_fixed_point_genus_at_least": 8, "general_first_fixed_point_genus_at_least": 4, "derivative_finite_branch_contacts": 18, "derivative_rational_infinity_points": 2, "derivative_fibers_everywhere_locally_soluble": true, "derivative_abelian_constant_slope_requires_fixed_root": true, "general_abelian_constant_slope_all_roots_free": true, "finite_small_class_menu_included": true, "individual_rational_witnesses_excluded": false, "global_realization_disproved": false, "general_variable_lower_bound": false, "arithmetic_foundations_needed_for_geometric_obstruction": false }, { "id": "actual_trace_vertical_and_affine_families", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/vertical_and_fixed_slope_20261117_v70.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/actual_trace_vertical_v70", "fixed_rational_input": true, "split_prime_lower_bound_exclusive": 7, "positive_odd_weight_valuation": true, "general_vertical_unit_lambda_plus_one_required": true, "general_prepared_abelian_families_constant": true, "general_all_nine_point_roles_free": true, "derivative_prepared_abelian_families_constant_with_fixed_root": true, "derivative_affine_slope_forces_root_trace_scale_slope_constant": true, "derivative_affine_relation": "z=m*a+b with fixed m,b in Q", "derivative_affine_requires_prime_hypothesis": false, "finite_small_class_menu_included": true, "individual_rational_witnesses_excluded": false, "unrestricted_derivative_root_and_slope_variation_excluded": false, "global_realization_disproved": false, "general_variable_lower_bound": false }, { "id": "sequential_six_unit_detector_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/quartic/sequential_unit_detector_obstruction_20261117_v70.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/sequential_units_v70", "ordered_extension_choices": 4664, "initial_s_basis_pairs": 3166, "globally_distinct_bases": 2834, "single_comparison_survivors": 2, "all_survivors_excluded_by_exact_factor_contradiction": true, "integer_Laurent_weights_unbounded": true, "all_quadratic_test_assignments_excluded": true, "literal_factor_equations_only": true, "monomial_row_division_only": true, "quadratic_test_powers": { "comparison": [ 9, 11 ], "raw": [ 1, 3 ] }, "initial_s": [ -2, -1, 0, 1, 2 ], "extra_sequential_units": 2, "SMT_needed_for_proof": false, "global_quartic_variable_lower_bound": false, "new_defining_variable_count": false }, { "id": "half_scalar_helper_quadratic_obstruction", "proof": "negative_results/papers/elliptic_charts/half_scalar_helper_20261117_v70.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/half_scalar_helper_v70", "rational_interface_coordinates": 21, "quadratic_monomials": 253, "quadratic_identity_dimension": 17, "evaluation_rank": 236, "certificate_prime": 1009, "nonzero_minor": 514, "characteristic_zero_specialization_justified": true, "nontorsion_false_scalar": { "true": "-2", "false": "1" }, "additional_global_coordinates_excluded_from_scope": true, "arbitrary_helpers_excluded_from_scope": true, "global_variable_lower_bound": false, "new_defining_variable_count": false }, { "id": "actual_raw_abscissa_preparation", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/raw_abscissa_preparation_20261117_v75.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/pole_parameters/raw_abscissa_v75", "prime": 76777, "actual_multiplication_tuple": true, "physical_slope": true, "negative_odd_pole_valuations": [ -1, -5 ], "trace_radicand_valuations": [ 1, 1 ], "all_pre_pole_character_guards": true, "global_completeness_failure_claimed": false }, { "id": "odd_halfpoint_raw_preparation", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/odd_coset_raw_20261117_v76.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/pole_parameters/odd_coset_raw_v76", "prime": 85817, "actual_multiplication_tuple": true, "physical_slope_progression": true, "negative_odd_pole_valuation": -11, "trace_radicand_valuation": 1, "all_pre_pole_character_guards": true, "global_completeness_failure_claimed": false }, { "id": "native_pole_forced_ramification", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/native_pole_ramification_20261117_v75.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/pole_parameters/native_pole_ramification_v75", "negative_odd_input_orders_excluded_over_geometric_valuations": true, "contact_counts": [ 10, 14, 18 ], "degree_two_genus_lower_bounds": [ 4, 6, 8 ], "genus_bound": "1+d*(r-4)/4", "specified_abelian_families_have_constant_slopes": true, "native_norm_actual_counterexample_prime": 100003, "native_norm_actual_counterexample_pole_valuation": -7, "individual_witnesses_excluded": false, "global_variable_lower_bound": false, "global_realization_disproved": false }, { "id": "adaptive_prepared_native_pairs", "proof": "negative_results/papers/pole_parameters/adaptive_prepared_pairs_20261117_v76.tex", "data": "negative_results/computation/pole_parameters/adaptive_prepared_pairs_v76", "prime": 100003, "fully_prepared_native_fixtures": 2, "every_added_local_scalar_excluded": true, "actual_elliptic_tuple_claimed": false, "global_realization_disproved": false } ] }